Encamera documents direct camera capture and encrypted media storage. Photo Vault imports existing media into a local archive; new and successfully migrated archives use AES-256-GCM with keys protected by a device-only installation key. If keeping new pictures out of the ordinary Photos capture workflow is essential, evaluate Encamera’s capture route; Photo Vault does not currently provide one.
Start with how the picture enters the library
An import workflow begins with an existing file. Moving a copy into another app does not establish what happened to the original, a synced copy or an earlier export. A direct camera workflow can avoid an initial Photos-library copy, but the actual capture and export behavior still deserves a small device test.
PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress 1.0 is live on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; always test your own import, export, and backup workflow before deleting originals. Archive encryption applies to new archives and successful migrations; the installation key is device-only, and final-build migration, export and recovery checks remain pending.
Compare the storage workflow
| Question | Encamera documentation | Photo Vault preview |
|---|---|---|
| New photos | In-app capture as well as import. | Import; no in-app camera. |
| Media protection | Published file-encryption code uses XChaCha20-Poly1305; the privacy policy says AES-256. Shipped build not audited. | Media is stored in a MOV container without app-level encryption. |
| Cloud option | Optional Premium storage in personal iCloud; separate key-backup setting. | No app-managed cloud sync. |
| Unlock options | Face ID, PIN or password in vendor documentation. | One selected method: password, pattern or device authentication; system authentication can allow the device passcode. |
| Public code | File-handling core is published. | This comparison uses our source review at d68c41e. |
| What to test | Capture destinations, export, and recovery. | Import quality, exports, and an independent-copy workflow. |
| Photo fidelity | Test exported files; no fidelity measurement in this review. | New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. Final export and sharing verification is pending. |
The encryption distinction matters
Photo Vault’s new format encrypts local media and current metadata writes using keys protected by a random installation key in this device’s Keychain. A password or pattern gates the interface and does not derive that key. Encamera also documents direct capture, which Photo Vault does not provide. We have not independently audited its shipped app, so this comparison cannot certify its key management or resistance to extraction.
Choose a trial that answers your question
For capture, take a harmless test picture, check the ordinary Photos library and inspect the app’s export destination. For an imported collection, try a detailed image, a long video and a Live Photo before moving a large library. Compare the exported files with the originals for detail, dimensions, motion, dates and sound. Keep the originals throughout the trial.
Decide how you will recover
Write down what should happen if the phone fails, you forget a credential or you replace the device. A cloud setting alone does not answer these questions. Verify which copy is complete, which credential opens it and whether you can recover a test item on the intended replacement device. Photo Vault has no app-operated recovery service, and device-backup restoration remains unverified.
Encamera documents a ten-word key phrase and optional key backup to iCloud Keychain. A backed-up key cannot replace missing media: verify that the encrypted files and the key are both available. The phrase is separate from the everyday unlock control. Photo Vault does not offer this key-phrase recovery workflow.
Disclosure and scope
Photo Vault’s developer wrote this comparison. Encamera information comes from linked vendor material; we did not test its current binary or buy a plan. Pricing, performance and successful recovery are not established here. Choose based on the capabilities you can verify, rather than a numerical security rating.
Sources & further reading
- Encamera product documentation
- Encamera privacy policy
- EncameraCore public repository and scope
- Encamera: key phrase and optional key backup, June 2026
- Encamera App Store listing and release notes