# Photo Vault vs Keepsafe: local archive or cloud vault?

> Compare encryption, provider access, cloud limits and photo quality in Photo Vault and Keepsafe. See what is documented and what remains untested.

Canonical page: https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/photo-vault-vs-keepsafe/

Arte Soft editorial team
Reviewed: 2026-10-20
Modified: 2026-10-20

Keepsafe documents encrypted media, optional private-cloud backup and email-based account recovery. Photo Vault has no app account or app-managed cloud sync; its new and successfully migrated local archives use encryption with a device-only installation key. Choose by your storage, recovery and key-control requirements rather than by the word vault.

## The first decision is where your copies live

A cloud option adds another place to recover from and another account to manage. A local archive removes the app-provider account from the workflow, but you must plan an independent copy. Neither model automatically answers who can decrypt extracted files or whether every item has been backed up.

PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress 1.0 is live on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; always test your own import, export, and backup workflow before deleting originals. Archive encryption applies to new archives and successful migrations; the installation key is device-only, and final-build migration, export and recovery checks remain pending.


## Compare the documented capabilities


Vendor documentation versus Photo Vault source review; not an independent security test

| Question | Keepsafe documentation | Photo Vault preview |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Media encryption | States AES-256 encryption at rest. Key architecture has not been independently verified here. | AES-256-GCM for new and successfully migrated archives; device-only installation key, separate from app credential. |
| Provider access | Says its service is not fully zero-knowledge and describes limited circumstances for content access. | No app account or app-managed cloud upload. Local archive encryption uses a device-only installation key; this is not a zero-knowledge cloud-service claim. |
| Account and recovery | Email access codes are part of sign-in and PIN recovery. | No account or support reset for a forgotten app credential. |
| Cloud copies | Optional backup/sync with plan-dependent capacity. | No app-managed cloud service. Device backup inclusion and restore require separate verification. |
| Cloud capacity | Support lists 200 items on Basic, 10,000 on monthly/yearly Premium and 100,000 on Lifetime. Check your current plan. | No Photo Vault cloud quota because there is no app-managed cloud service. |
| Photo quality and storage | Space Saver stores originals in its cloud and smaller copies on the phone, according to support. | New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. Final export and sharing verification is pending. |
| Switching phones | Documents cloud transfer and a manual export/import route. | Export and verify copies before retiring the old phone. |
| Exact cost | Check the offer for your account, region and current plan. | Price and release listing have not been verified. |

## Plan the organization after a move

Photo Vault’s updated archive supports editable albums and search across filenames, album titles, dates and available recognized text. Its import path can reconcile available Apple Photos album memberships, but this is not continuous synchronization with Photos or a direct import of a Keepsafe album database.

Before moving a large collection, export a small album and check which dates, names and groupings actually reach Photo Vault. Recreate any missing organization before repeating the workflow at scale. Photo Vault albums reference existing archive items, so adding a picture to another album does not create a second media copy. These details are source-reviewed at e27c10f; the cross-app migration remains untested.


## Encryption does not settle who can access content

Keepsafe’s support page dated October 22, 2019 says the service is not completely zero-knowledge. It describes possible access for support you request, legal requirements and suspected terms or privacy-policy violations. This is the provider’s description, not a finding that employees routinely view users’ photos.

Photo Vault has no app-provider account or cloud-library service. Its new media format and current metadata writes use encryption protected by a random installation key, rather than a constant shared by installations. The key is held in this device’s Keychain and is separate from the app credential. This source review is not a security audit; copied encrypted files alone are not a recovery method.


## A cloud mirror has limits

Keepsafe’s backup article, dated December 6, 2023 and checked for this comparison, lists the item allowances in the table. A quota is not proof that your entire library has finished syncing. Check both the allowance on your account and which items are backed up.

Keepsafe describes its cloud as a mirror: synced Trash items still use the quota, and emptying them from Trash removes them from the app and cloud. Keep a separate copy if you need protection against deleting an item in the app. A synchronized cloud library is not necessarily an independent historical archive.


## Compare the files you can take with you

For Keepsafe with Space Saver enabled, follow its instructions to download full-size files before a migration and inspect a sample export. New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. Keep independent originals and verify the actual exported resource; a sharp preview does not prove file preservation.

Check a Live Photo’s movement and sound as well as its still image. Also inspect ordinary video playback and relevant metadata. We have not performed a complete migration between these apps or verified every media format; use the linked export guide for a trial you can check.


## A useful trial before choosing

Use a small set of non-sensitive photos and a video. Import them, test the chosen unlock method, and export them to a destination you control. Check dimensions, dates, playback and sound. For a cloud workflow, check which items report completed backup rather than assuming the entire gallery is protected.


## When each may fit

If you need a provider-supported recovery and device-transfer route, examine Keepsafe’s documented service and your email security. PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress describes a separate local gallery without an app account, using compressed media and separate encrypted metadata for new Lossy imports. Its archive encryption uses a device-only installation key. Compare local encryption, Secure Share export, and backup requirements on your own device before migrating sensitive libraries.


## Evidence and limits

This comparison is written by Photo Vault’s developer. Keepsafe statements are attributed to its support pages, including pages with older update dates; we have not tested its current binary, key management or restore process. Photo Vault statements incorporate the e49fbcf source review; they do not describe a verified working release. Recheck the live product before making a purchase or removing originals.


## Sources & further reading

- [Keepsafe Support: how data is protected](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/360035454311-How-does-Keepsafe-protect-my-data>)
- [Keepsafe Support: backup and sync](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/209134046-How-does-the-Keepsafe-backup-work>)
- [Keepsafe Support: transferring to a new phone](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/209134126-How-do-I-transfer-photos-to-a-new-phone>)
- [Keepsafe: provider access (October 2019)](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/360035082512-Can-Keepsafe-see-any-of-my-content>)
- [Keepsafe: Space Saver (November 2023)](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/210730763-What-is-Space-Saver>)
- [Keepsafe: download full-size files (May 2024)](<https://support.getkeepsafe.com/hc/en-us/articles/209134146-How-do-I-turn-Space-Saver-off>)

## Keep exploring

- [Keepsafe review: backup, recovery and provider access](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/photo-vault-vs-keepsafe/review/>)
- [How to switch from Keepsafe to another photo vault](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/switch-from-keepsafe-photo-vault/>)
- [Compare photo privacy options](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/>)
- [Photo Vault security: encryption, app lock and sharing](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/security/>)
- [Photo Vault image quality: resolution, compression and exports](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/photo-vault-full-resolution-iphone/>)
- [Export photos and videos from Photo Vault](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/export-photos-from-vault-app-iphone/>)
- [Search Photo Vault by text, date, album and place](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/search-photo-vault/>)
- [Create and organize albums in Photo Vault](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/organize-photo-vault-albums/>)

---

## Official App Store Download (PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress)

- **App Store (iPhone & iPad, Free Download)**: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id6824412013?pt=127093297&ct=geo_md_vault&mt=8
- **App ID**: `6824412013` · **System**: iOS 26+ / iPadOS 26+
- **Encryption & Storage**: Local AES-256-GCM vault + optional HEVC compression + Password, Pattern & Face ID/Touch ID + `.pvsecure` Secure Share
- **Website & Documentation**: https://photovault.arte-soft.com/
